Can We Trust Those Who Feed Us? PDF E-mail
Boyd Pearson   
Tuesday, 05 June 2007
 
I know I’m just another person in a large audience applauding Google, but you have to be amazed at how they just keep doing everything right.

 

Buying Feedburner is HUGE (in an all caps kind of way). For those of you who don’t know who Feedburner is, they provide custom RSS feeds and management tools to web-based content publishers.

 

(I recently discovered that I take for granted understanding what RSS is and how to use it. There are still many that don’t use RSS. So, if you are unaware of the power of RSS, please see this video. If you aren’t using RSS, you should. It makes your web experience SO much more simplified, streaming videos and information directly into your aggregator. Thus, you can create your own web experience—your own virtual newspaper so to speak.)

 

With this purchase, Google now not only learns a ton more about people, but also buys itself another advertising platform. So, Google obtains more information and another stream of revenue. They just keep hitting homeruns. However, with this purchase, there is a bit of another Google “ick factor.”

 

Now, I love Google. I even trust them. However, they are learning more and more about me. They have my e-mail. They have my video . They know where I live. And now they know everything that I like . (This is also why eBay’s purchase of StumbleUpon is so smart. Off the record, Google people will tell you that they view eBay as a serious competitor.)

 

It’s just all a bit weird to me. Privacy is disappearing. (It’s possibly already disappeared.) Good or bad, that’s the reality. Your experience online is becoming more customized and personalized. By setting up the web up any way that you like, you get fed what you want to consume. But these giants of the web know what you’re eating. And it’s heading towards the day when they’ll be feeding you ads about the things only you like and "want" to hear about. This is already happening to some degree, though somewhat exaggerated.

 

Ickiness, strangeness aside, I’m glad it’s Google and not others. Google is becoming the king of advertising, and more importantly, it is the king of the web. So, at least a progressive company has all of my information. (In my opinion, only a progressive company can make these strides and hit these homeruns, but that’s another post.)

 

So, is all this a good thing? You have the crowd saying, “Yeah, it is. If I’m going to constantly be bombarded with advertising, then it might is well be about things I’m interested in and want.” And then you have the other crowd saying, “Sure, but what about privacy? Isn’t a little scary that all these companies ‘know’ what I want?” It’s an interesting predicament.

 

In my opinion, with the customizable and personalized nature of the web, we must concern ourselves with privacy. What if this info gets into the wrong hands? Does that question even matter, as it's already all been gathered and is in so many hands? Who is looking out for us, the users? These, and many others, are questions for a larger debate, but certainly questions in deep need of consideration.



Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!

Comments (5)Add Comment
Endgame for "advertising"
written by Eric Raymond, June 05, 2007 07:36 PM
I suspect that Google will one day eliminate what we think of these days as advertising. You will not be bombarded with ads for things you like-- you will just be bombarded with things you like. Google will largely control that process, and the concept of hiring an "agency" to create a "spot" that 3% of people will sit through will seem as obsolete as making sure that the water trough is full for the horses tied up out front.

One downside to this is a preposterously boring universe. If you're never introduced to things you hate or things you would only run into by chance, interests (and growth) can be somewhat limited.

As to privacy: One side effect of gathering data on everyone is the cumbersome process of storing and retrieving that information. This is no longer the challenge it once was. What is still somewhat challenging is writing the right sort of questions to get the information you want out of the data ocean. Even this will likely be solved.

Perhaps you cannot have your privacy online, but the story you write about yourself online can be shaped or distorted to your liking. If you can undermine the validity of the information, then you may be able to at least wriggle out of Big Brother's grasp. Afraid they know everything? Cultivate your disinformation and dillute your identity.

Or, take solace in the fact that all of this data is often just one big Electro Magnetic Pulse away from non-existence. Magnetic storage can be very unforgiving.

E.
broker
written by Patrick, June 05, 2007 07:51 PM
The big shift, in my mind, that drives the change Eric is talking about: Google will become (already is) the primary BROKER of advertising...the exact opposite of an AGENT. The party represented changes. It is fundamental to the business model that is working for them and unsettling the AGENCIES. Ad brokering, it's the new plastics, kid.
Do I Know What I Really Want?
written by teriktm, June 06, 2007 02:44 PM
I go for Eric's comment about the boring universe. Whatever happened to surprise and delight? Now, though we'll have web tools that help us "stumbleupon" other thoughts, opinions, ideas - there will be no advertising that will stretch us beyond our proven, demonstrated "likes"? I don't see it happening - Google or no Google. They can be an efficient broker, they can screw up the agencies - but I see people acutally making a game of thwarting behavioral targeting. YOU DON"T KNOW ME will be the bumper sticker of the next generation.

Are we about the journey we're on or the destination we're at? Sometimes I want more of the same proven things i know and love. And other times I want to discover something I haven't even heard of yet. And sometimes I want to act, be, consume completely out of character. Some days, I want to do all three.
Identity Scmidentity
written by Steven Rogers, June 07, 2007 06:17 PM
I come back from the dead to tell you that your complaint is feeble-minded. Merely do as Eric suggests and create multiple personalities. That is what is beautiful about life. You aren't stuck as who you are. You can always change.

portfolio of self
written by swimtoshore, June 08, 2007 12:49 PM
multiple identities -
multiple spouses, multiple jobs -

Don't want to manage a portfolio of self -
Want to curate my own life - thanks for the targeting, but NO thanks.

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote

busy