Duking it out in the Classroom PDF E-mail
Teri A. Schindler   
Sunday, 13 May 2007
 
Here’s the bottom line problem with cheating in business school. It doesn’t help you in business.

 

The workplace is desperate for good skills, good ideas and good thinking to deal with the accelerated pace of change today. This current environment poses a lot of questions; most of which do not have simple “right” answers. Because this is Duke we’re talking about at the moment, a basketball analogy seems apt. In hoops they talk about the pass before the pass. By this, serious fans mean the action that sets up and enables the ultimate success of the play. The pass before the pass is not usually replayed in game and rarely shows up on Sportscenter highlights. For the most part, it remains uncelebrated (except by aficionados) – but it is absolutely vital for successful execution.

 

Translation for a business playbook: Often it’s about the questions you ask, not the answers you memorize.

 

It wasn’t always like this. Recently, I discussed the current landscape with a strategist at a top consumer entertainment company. We were talking about how difficult the decision making process had become. I maintained that executives used to pronounce pompously “this is the way it’s done,” but that they no longer could. He argued that they still utter that phrase – but, he allowed, now they say it with a note of fear, not arrogance.

 

Beware, ambitious B-school students. Cheating is not like breast augmentation where the perceived benefits stay with you for life. An MBA with an artificially–enhanced GPA will immediately feel the pressure of the real world where there is nowhere to turn for extra, surreptitious, illicit “help.” The ugly truth is that once you leave school and start working, your GPA is irrelevant – and it certainly won’t save you from drowning in the sea of conflicting information, shifting paradigms and disruptive business models.

 

That’s not to say it won’t land you that plum first job and put you into the system at an elevated level that will bring financial benefits for years to come. Or that it isn’t a guaranteed network. And it’s not to say that organizations don’t cover their fannies by selecting MBA’s from a certain institutions because even if the employees don’t work out they can always claim they “should have” – it’s a degree that largely mitigates the risk of the hiring process.

 

But most managers will tell you their valuable employees are employees with certain characteristics – a willingness to roll up their sleeves, an ability to consider a fresh approach, pattern recognition. As one c-level executive lamented recently “It’s just really so much harder than you’d think to find good, smart, hardworking people.”

 

Bring me a graduate who is more than the sum of his transcript – and I’ll give you a valuable employee.


Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!

Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote

busy