Poison Me Once, Shame on China; Poison Me Twice, Shame on America. PDF E-mail
J. Kevin Ament   
Tuesday, 14 August 2007

 

It appears Baby Einstein isn’t the only company peddling products that may retard our children. On Tuesday, toy maker Mattel announced its second major recall in as many weeks.

 

Regarded as one of the safest toy manufacturers in America, Mattel’s well-earned reputation is flaking off faster than lead-laced paint chips from a Fisher-Price figurine. Mattel Chairman Bob Eckert would have you believe it’s those damn Chinese, but when will American companies start taking responsibility for their supply chain decisions?

 

This morning, in several national newspapers, a full-page apology from Bob followed the crisis management team’s bullet points to the letter. Bob calmly explained that "Nothing is more important than the safety of our children." Now I don’t expect executive seppuku or government executions, but I’d like to see a little candor.

 

I’d like to see Bob step in front of a camera and say “We’ve sacrificed safety for low price for the last time. It’s time American corporations wake up. We can’t have our low-cost toys and eat them too. We must stop building our brands upon the Chinese Manufacturing house of cards.” Instead we got “solution-oriented” flimflam. And that’s dangerous.

 

It’s dangerous because as long as we focus on individual recalls, the true scope of the problem remains hidden. We need a real dialogue about the costs of our low, low prices, and that means looking beyond Wal-Mart. Sub-par manufacturing practices farmed out to the lowest bidder are making us sick, killing our pets, and putting our children at risk. American brands need to make fundamental changes, or soon shoppers won’t differentiate between a tag that reads “Made in China,” and one that reads “Mattel.”

 



Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!

Comments (15)Add Comment
toying with our kids' health
written by holly, August 14, 2007 05:02 PM
Thank you for writing about this. I'd like to think that when I buy a Mattel or Fisher Price product for my child, it passed some kind of safety test. Sadly, that's not the case. Who is looking out for our kids? And we are far too dependent on China for our products. There was a woman interviewed on Today recently. She and her family went for a whole year without buying anything that was made in China. She said it was almost impossible, and Christmas wasn't very fun in their house, but she did it to prove an important point. I think she wrote a book about it, too. I'll try to find it and post another comment.
Guess they got the same crisis management team.
written by Nothing is More Important, August 14, 2007 05:08 PM
More proof that crisis "flimflam" is meaningless...

Press release from the recent Purina petfood recall:
"At Purina, nothing is more important to us than the health and well-being of the pets whose nutrition has been entrusted to us by their owners."

and

"Nothing is more important to us than the health and well-being of the millions of dogs and cats who eat our food, and we are deeply saddenedby this situation."

From the HIT Entertainment/RC2 Corp. Thomas the Train figurine recall:
"All customers deserve to know that all Thomas & Friends products are safe for them. Nothing is more important to us than ensuring that this is the case, and rebuilding your trust and loyalty."

Press release from the recent FTS Tire Recall:
"Nothing is more important to us than the safety of consumers who use our tires."

Press release from the Firestone tire recall:
"At Bridgestone/Firestone, nothing is more important to us than the safety of our consumers."

"Distributed by..."
written by bkostl, August 14, 2007 05:10 PM
After the toothpaste scare I started trying to identify the origins of my food and personal hygiene products. More often than not, they're merely labeled Imported and "Distributed by XYZ." Finding the country of origin based on packaging alone isn't always easy. I also learned that Denmark apparently makes a lot of chewing gum. Who knew.
I'll (pretty little) pony up
written by senorita sarape, August 14, 2007 05:22 PM
I'll gladly pay extra for a toy if I can be assured that my children won't have long-term health issues from playing with it. Or maybe I'll just learn to whittle our own toys. That should go over well with the kids. But at least they'll just get splinters and not brain damage.
A Year Without "Made in China": One Family's True Life Adventure in the Global Economy
written by holly, August 14, 2007 05:29 PM
Here's that book I mentioned. It just came out. The author is Sarah Bongiorni. Looks really interesting. http://www.amazon.com/Year-Without-Made-China-Adventure/dp/0470116137/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/104-3678887-9083157?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1187130348&sr=1-1
it turned out to be true
written by Lady Humps, August 15, 2007 01:36 AM
unfair. just wrong. but i have to say it. the childhood (and childish) song is true: me chinese. me play joke. me put pee pee in your coke. yep. yah sure did. but we asked for it. you get what you pay for. bring back MADE IN AMERICA.
Here they come
written by Snoball Effect, August 15, 2007 06:55 AM
This is just the beginning. We're going to see a dozen more of these before the end of the year now that the issue is out there.

http://money.cnn.com/2007/08/15/news/companies/lead_bibs/?postversion=2007081507

Lead in bibs? It's a bib, people. I swear this is the Chinese strategy to replace US as superpower.
new ad campaign for Mattel
written by jackie wells, August 15, 2007 09:58 AM
And here they go with the damage control. And you'll note the "Nothing is more important than the safety of our children" message. http://adage.com/article.php?article_id=119871

Obama Throws First Punch
written by The Big O, August 15, 2007 10:06 AM
Obama came out first and wrote a letter to the US Trade Representative. Here's the text. Are 86% of American toys really made in China? Good lord.

Dear Ambassador Schwab:

I am writing to urge the Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) to take aggressive action to protect America’s children from toys containing harmful levels of lead that are imported from China. This is a serious issue that compromises the health of children throughout the country.

While lead paint has been banned in the United States since 1978, nearly half a million children continue to suffer from lead poisoning. Lead is a highly toxic substance that can produce a range of health problems in young children including IQ deficiencies, reading and learning disabilities, reduced attention spans, hyperactivity, and damage to the kidneys, brain and bone marrow. Though the most common source of lead exposure is from lead paint in older homes, children are exposed to lead in other ways, including through the toys they play with in their homes, playgrounds, and schools.

As you are no doubt aware, in recent months, there have been a number of high-profile recalls of children’s products manufactured in China:

* In March 2007, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announced three separate recalls of 108,600 units of children's necklaces and 128,700 “Elite Operations? toy sets due to high lead paint content.

* In April, 4 million •Groovy Grabber? bracelets and 396,000 metal key chains were recalled because of high lead content.

* In May, 103,000 pieces of metal jewelry marketed in conjunction with •High School Musical? were recalled because of high lead content.

* In June, the RC2 Corporation recalled 1.5 million Thomas & Friends wooden toy railway sets that were coated with excessive levels of lead paint.

* Two weeks ago, Mattel announced the recall of 83 types of toys worldwide because the paint in the toys contained excessive amounts of lead. This worldwide recall involved almost 1 million plastic preschool toys, including the popular Big Bird, Elmo, Dora and Diego characters.

* And just today, Mattel announced the recall of 253,000 toy jeeps featuring the Sarge character from the movie •Cars.?

Since we first learned about the dangers of these products, the CPSC has taken steps to remove these toys from store shelves. But recent product recalls raise a larger question about whether our government should take proactive steps to prevent the importation of potentially dangerous children•s products, particularly toys manufactured in China.

In 2006, China was the largest importer of toys, dolls, and games to the American marketplace. These imports total $14.6 billion and account for 86% of total U.S. imports of toys, dolls, and games. Although most of these toys are safe, recent events suggest that a number of Chinese manufacturers are cutting corners and using cheap and illegal substitutes such as lead paint. The resulting lower prices of many foreign-made toys are attractive, especially to low-income families, who, along with the rest of our citizens, trust that products imported into the United States undergo a thorough inspection. Unfortunately, it appears that their trust may be misplaced.

If we have an opportunity to protect our nation’s most vulnerable population – our children – from harmful toxins, we should do so, and a good place to start is safeguarding their toys. Since the USTR is responsible for developing and coordinating U.S. international trade policy and overseeing negotiations with other countries, I am interested in learning the following:

* Given the large number of toys imported from China with high lead levels, has USTR raised concerns about this issue with the Chinese government? If so, what is the response of the Chinese government to these concerns?
* If these concerns have not been raised with the Chinese government, does USTR intend to raise this issue in the near future?

I request that you respond to these questions by August 21, 2007. Thank you.

Sincerely,

Barack Obama
United States Senator
...
written by Hilary, August 15, 2007 11:08 AM
Good for Barack. Americans cannot accept a simple apology and promise to do better from these companies. We need to demand more from the toy companies and more from our government. I wonder what would happen if people start organizing mass drop offs of toys made in China or called for nationwide boycotts of these products. It may be tough to live without toys made in China, but its better than seeing our children poisoned by the very toys that should bring them joy and comfort, not harm.
It is not just the Chinese. Many suppliers try to cut corners
written by Roger Anderson, August 15, 2007 11:39 AM
If a company wants to be irresponsible by not testing the products sent to them then they deserve to take the hit. Unfortunately, in this situation it seems easy to point to the source. If you ask your kid to clean his room and you do not check up repeatedly, she will soon learn not to worry about doing a good job. China, Mexico, Japan, UK, and anywhere you have to deal with people outside your legal reach you have to take precautions.

Mattel is not the first or last but they should step up higher this time. This is why I wrote my piece last night in such a huff Mattel Recall - Where Are the Outraged Bloggers? http://www.modernmagellans.com/2007/08/mattel_recall_what_are_you_say.html
Who are to blame _ the Chinese manufacturer or the American retailer
written by Alex Yau, August 16, 2007 07:41 AM
The price of oil rises from 30 dollar to 75 dollar, PLASTIC one of the major material used for toys rises the same at about the same rate since it is a by-product from oil. It was since the year of 2004, but the retail price did not, does not and possibly will not reflex the cost increased. Would anyone wondering why when you shopped? Is that the Chinsese manufacturer earning a lot already? The answer is negative.
A simple calculation is the cost the manufacturer allowed to sell to a major retailer is usually 1/4 of the retailer price. For instance, when you see a product sells at 10.00. The retailer spent about 2.50 to buy from the manufacturers. With general cost increase such as labour, and raw material. The manufacturers can not and could not increase the cost for about 5%. It can't hardly cover the increaes. So the manufacturers can only find a way in order to survive. And hopefully it will change somehow. Unfortunately, it did not. So the manufacturers left only one option is to pray to have all of the products sold, otherwise the retailers will come back for "mark-down". Some of the better one, they will only come for mark-down money when the sales does not reach to 85%. And mark-down means the product has to be dropped to one price point so as trying to have to stock quickly moved. And the manufacturers will have to pay the retail a sum of momey for the action taken. If they refuse to pay them the money, it will only guranttee to loose a chance for the next season or worst completely taken out from the vendor list. So whom to blame, the manufactures in China, or .....
Um.
written by Kungfu Fighting, August 16, 2007 04:33 PM
Uh. Well said, Alex.
my danghter jade{leadpoison/autistic}out come of lead-is autism
written by sandra, November 03, 2007 09:07 AM
my daughter jade was lead poison in her 1st yr,then in her 2nd yr was diagnosis with autism,she is 7yrs old now and the out come of lead poison is to my belief autism,although i can not prove tis yet!i will in a book call peices,if lead was band 30 yrs ago i beleve the raising numbers of autism would be less,i have spent thousands of dollars on what i believed to be safe for my already lead poison daughter,as a total recall knowing there is no moneys back,i would,like jades toys replaced for christmas,with safe [lead free]toys,and the 1st toy lead-free on your toy boxes along with jades picture and a labeled called [band], instead of im sorry to china ,that makes me and I"m sure a million other parents of lead poison children,SICK.you are poisoning our children and their furtures of the american,you should be sorry to these american children,and band lead for good then you may see the numbers of autism go down i truely with out a doubt believe the results of a lead poison child is autism if you spent the day with a lead poison child you would get an idea what you are doing to the future of these children,and to the future of the american with autism,what is the american dream going to be then?sandra schunk
band lead-less autism
written by sandra, November 03, 2007 09:44 AM
band lead ,less autism,the belief of a mother who's daughter was lead poison 6yrs ago and now lives in the world of autism still sitting in silents for 7 yrs.

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote

busy