Hey, Alli, Does This Dignity Make My Butt Look Big? PDF E-mail
J. Kristin Ament   
Sunday, 08 July 2007

 

The new fat-blasting wonder drug, alli, is terrifying. I’m talking “Poltergeist” clown terrifying. The product poses some unique marketing challenges, to say the least.

 

Weight loss is an occasional topic of discussion in my house. I’ve had two kids in the past two years, and my husband packed on some sympathy weight each time. Babies aside, if someone were to show up at our house on any given evening and say “Hey, who’s up for Chinese?” we’d turn feral, running in circles and drooling all over ourselves. Yeah, we dig food and would love a magic pill to make the weight drop off without having to do anything.

 

I tried the whole Akins thing a few years back. Being a carb fiend, I lost my mind within a matter of days. By day four, I was chewing up chocolate and spitting it out into my office trash can before the evil carbs would kick in. Then, looking at a pile of spitty, half-chewed Dove dark chocolates, I had my moment of clarity: losing a few pounds simply isn’t worth sacrificing one’s pride and sense of humanity.

 

This brings me to alli. You’ve probably seen the in-store displays or the ads – GlaxoSmithKline has been busting it on the marketing front. I thought it was pronounced “Allie,” like a girlfriend, but it’s pronounced “ally,” presumably because it’s all suited up and ready to join in the battle against the evil dictator of back fat. But the more I learn about alli, the more I think it’s the last thing I’d want anywhere near me on the battlefield. Or in any situation where there’s another person within a 10 mile radius of me.

 

The basic gist of the FDA-approved, OTC drug is that it can help you lose 50 percent more weight than just by dieting. It blocks dietary fat from being absorbed by the body. And since the fat isn’t going into your body, it has to come out. Apparently driven out of your intestines in a car with a Papa John’s sign on top:

 

The excess fat that passes out of your body is not harmful. In fact, you may recognize it as something that looks like the oil on top of a pizza.

 

Now there’s some fine marketing lingo. And yet it gets uglier. Alli calls possible complications by the pleasant sounding name “treatment effects.” I prefer to call them “horsemen of the apocalypse.” The site says:

 

Learning how to manage treatment effects is an important part of being successful with alli.

 

And it then offers a few suggestions to “take control.” My personal favorite is:

 

You may feel an urgent need to go to the bathroom. Until you have a sense of any treatment effects, it's probably a smart idea to wear dark pants, and bring a change of clothes with you to work.

 

Alrighty then. So before you take the pills, just invest in dark pants, pack a suitcase to bring to work each day, give your dry cleaner the ol’ heads up, Scotchgard your chair and tell your boss that you’ll be setting up an office in the restroom. Easy.

 

In all seriousness, how did we get to a point where we are willing to soil ourselves publicly in an attempt to achieve society's idea of beauty?

 

Everyone fell over themselves to applaud Dove’s Campaign for Real Beauty for finally doing something to build self-esteem rather than erode it. The industry threw all kinds of impressive awards at it. But, honestly, is America really ready to celebrate normal-sized people? If so, why do drug manufacturers, who aren’t the type to spend billions without a few market research bullets bolstering their R&D, find a path to market with products like this? Is the consumer who buys Dove soap because she wants to feel accepted still going to take alli because, deep down, she knows that our culture doesn’t share Dove’s rosy optimism?

 

This is hardly the magic pill I had in mind. If pride and public decorum weigh about ten pounds and tend to hang out around the gut and hips, I’ll just keep them where they are, thanks.



Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!

Comments (22)Add Comment
donuts...
written by josemocha, July 09, 2007 12:09 AM
...make my brown eye blue.

these people have missed the point. if it is "excess" fat that is being spontaneously ass-spat out, then the problem is "excess." Call alli the "post meal portion control pill." Or the, "cake and pooped it too pill." Wake up folks: if you don't want to be fat, eat less and exercise more. It is a simple equation.

Now, for my burrrrrritos.
...
written by I smell something funky, July 09, 2007 09:17 AM
If these are the side effects now, what will the future bring for people taking this drug? Keep in mind that fen-phen was once FDA approved as well...
Pavlov's Logs
written by Wet Blanket, July 09, 2007 09:42 AM
Incredible.

While no one likes experiencing treatment effects, they might help you think twice about eating questionable fat content.

Thank you treatment effects! The social shame and professional handicap of my morbid obesity wasn't motivation enough. Facing the additional taboo of sudden, uncontrollable bowel release helped me overcome the urge to indulge!

This is all so surreal. They're marketing this pill as a super-ego supplement. Taking a pill that ups the social repurcussions for overeating, like having your stomach surgically reduced to the size of a walnut so that it's physically impossible to over-eat, suggest we are no longer in control of our bodies and must rely on science to save us from our own self-detructive behaviors - proof that this is a sociological problem, not just a physical health epidemic. Mass obesity is a side-effect of the real illness, and it's cultural, not medical.
"treatment effects"
written by Moontrot, July 09, 2007 09:47 AM
It's interesting to see marketing copy that is so disturbingly honest ("wear dark pants" because you're likely to crap yourself) juxtaposed with the bs phrase "treatment effects." Of course, I guess "side effects" wouldn't be entirely accurate either, because essentially the drug is designed for you to crap away the fat.
...
written by Montezuma's Revenge, July 09, 2007 09:50 AM
"Limit fat intake in your meals to an average of 15 grams." Or watch what you eat. Come on.
...
written by Wet Blanket, July 09, 2007 10:01 AM
That's what's so interesting, Monte. The reason this pill works is that if you eat more than 15 grams, you crap yourself. It's negative reinforcement. Standard reduced-fat diets push the same plan. The difference is the "treatment effects." They're marketing will-power through social humiliation rather than a nutritionally different approach to dieting. The science is the same, it's the psychology that's changed.
...
written by Wet Blanket, July 09, 2007 10:25 AM
Kristin mentions Dove's "rosy optimism," and it reminds me of Patrick's post on Mainstream Brands (http://www.unboundedition.com/content/view/980/54/). Dove's campaign, like Saturn's Rethink campaign, is aspirational, but alli bucks that trend and markets to reality. The truth is, even if we want people to look past our frumpy appearance, we can't. Popular culture's celebration of anorexia is too strong. And most of us aren't going to diet and exercise. Why not be honest?

Olestra whethered the "anal leakage" nomenclature, and the FDA no longer requires the warning. It's still out there, causing "loose stools." The science is the science. That fat has to go somewhere. More pharm manufacturers are going to face this same marketing language challenge. At least alli is isn't fibbing to its consumers.
hmmm... let'ssever this and see what happens
written by Thickburgler, July 09, 2007 11:15 AM
Add this one to your list of insane measures, Wet Blanket.

http://www.cnn.com/2007/HEALTH/conditions/07/09/obesity.nerve.ap/index.html

Now they're just snipping stuff in the ole' noggin, hoping it curbs appetite. Let me save you the suspense, people. If you run a pair of tweezers across my gray matter and I suddenly stop stuffing my gaw with Mike and Ikes, don't jump to any conclusions. It may be, just MAY be your poking on my brain that's got me down.

What's with these people!

...
written by verve, July 09, 2007 01:34 PM
Really funny post about alli...

http://angryaussie.wordpress.com/2007/06/20/miracle-diet-pill-with-teeny-tiny-side-effect/

Eek!
written by jean, July 09, 2007 03:28 PM
Looks like the public sullying could be the least of your problems if you take Alli:

http://v.mercola.com/blogs/public_blog/Doctors-Outraged--FDA-Ignored-Cancer-Risk-When-Approving-Alli-26668.aspx

Watch alli in action
written by angry american, July 09, 2007 06:36 PM
LOVE the comment on Angry 365 Days a year to "watch alli in action". He made his own video too: http://angryaussie.wordpress.com/2007/06/20/laugh-i-nearly-shit-my-pants/


Oops! I crapped my skinny pants!
written by I'm not fat, I'm fluffy., July 10, 2007 07:18 AM
In all seriousness, how did we get to a point where we are willing to soil ourselves publicly in an attempt to achieve society's idea of beauty?


No kidding! Crapping ourselves, Starving ourselves, hating ourselves, paying someone to carve us up or vacuum us out ... just to look a little thinner? Come on, people. Get real.

The goal of Internet spewing is to get readers.....not necessarily to spout out any sort of real truth
written by bill, July 11, 2007 04:09 PM
Are the side effects of Alli guranteed to hit everyone? Nope. Is the degree to which any side effect happens going to be the same for everyone? Nope? Since Alli IS Xenical/Orlistat...is there any historical data showing all users for the past years are unable to function in society when taking Xenical/Orlistat/Alli? Nope.

But the original writer says there are some terrifying things going on here. Ha-ha.

I've been on Alli for four weeks. I have a relatively low fat diet, lots of exercise and the side effects of Alli have been marginal to none. But I've lost 3 pounds more than in the same four week period before I started Alli. So.....it works. For at least one person. And my guess is that I'm not the only one. And nothing in my body blew up in the process. Which pretty much negates everything presented in the first article. No terrifying stuff going on here folks.

As an FYI, I'm also going to try Acomplia soon as it has the really useful trigger....completely turning off the hunger desire. I'm working at knocking off 25 pounds and I think Accomplia (fda approved or not) is showing such great results in Europe (where it is approved) that I'm going to try it. No doubt that when Acomplia is approved in the US in the next 2-3 years, the writer of the original Alli article here will spit out a new blog, screaming to run for the hills because if you take Acomplia, you'll go into a deep depression and blow your brains out.....or something similar. Anything to get readers.
wtf!?
written by BobDoleSez, July 11, 2007 04:48 PM
BobDoleSez: Bill, wtf? I think the original article was QUOTING Alli materials, not screaming and running for the hills. Why so defensive? And if Alli is so grand, why already the pill pangs for the next drug? Grand that you haven't pooped in your office chair. But the COMPANY, not the author, advises you and others to wear dark clothes and keep the bedpan attached or close by. BobDoleSez: get off the pot and shit.
...
written by Beaners, July 11, 2007 10:19 PM
My sister started Alli about a month after I started my own weight loss diet. I went to a nutritionist, who tested my resting metabolic rate and told me the specific number of calories I may eat per day to achieve my weight loss goals. Healthy choices are recommended, but basically I am denied nothing as long as when I have eaten my alloted daily calories, I STOP EATING UNTIL THE NEXT DAY. This seems to be working for me. I have my own little experiment going with my sister....by the way, she said she knew nothing about the warning for people with thyroid disease, and now claims "two doctors have signed off" on her taking the Alli. I'd bet money that hasn't happened and is just a part of the denial which will ALWAYS keep her fat. She's still looking for the magic pill. I'm looking at a lot of hard work and exercise. I wish her luck but I haven't seen any results yet.
No laughing matter
written by Joe Smoe, July 11, 2007 10:38 PM
josemocha wrote: "Wake up folks: if you don't want to be fat, eat less and exercise more. It is a simple equation."

It must not be quite that simple when, according to the CDC, "In 2005, only 4 states had obesity prevalence rates less than 20 percent, while 17 states had prevalence rates equal to or greater than 25 percent, with 3 of those having prevalences equal to or greater than 30 percent (Louisiana, Mississippi, and West Virginia)," and, according to Forbes, Americans "spent an estimated $46 billion on diet products and self-help books" that same year. The flippant "eat less, exercise more" response is sounding pretty hallow at this point.

I'm not fat, I'm fluffy wrote: "Crapping ourselves, Starving ourselves, hating ourselves, paying someone to carve us up or vacuum us out ... just to look a little thinner? Come on, people. Get real."

Another flip response. Of course, some people are looking to lose 5 or 10 vanity pounds (like the author of this essay, apparently), but there are many more Americans who have serious weight problems and need to lose a significant amount.

For millions of Americans, trying to lose weight is not "attempt to achieve society's idea of beauty" but an attempt to prevent heart attacks, strokes, diabetes, cancer, immobility, etc. The author asks if America is "really ready to celebrate normal-sized people." Who is suggesting that normal-sized people should take this product?

One last note: I have not tried Alli myself, but I know two people who are taking it with no adverse effects and have found it a helpful tool. What's wrong with that?
accepting advice....
written by rookie, July 21, 2007 06:11 PM
I have not tried Alli YET. I may spend the $ 50 just in hopes that it actually helps....even a little. I love the idea to eat less and exercise more. That sounds great and for many people, works great. The math makes sense. If you are burning more calories than you are consuming, you should lose the weight. This has always made sense to me but unfortunately now that I need to lose some weight ( just for self esteem purposes) the numbers aren't adding up. For all the "it's easy, just do this" comments...Please share. I am 28 years of age, no child birth weight gain...just natural weight gain. I'm young and still in good enough shape to exercise at least 4-5...(sometimes 6) days a week and eating the healthiest I have in years...to no avail. The weight is not budging. If Alli works a little and helps to lose the weight, I'm in....anal leakage and all. My eating habit is already great so if it helps rid my body of all the toxins that I am ingesting, great.
to hell with bill
written by TruKuta, July 24, 2007 12:01 PM
honestly bill, you are nothing more than a mouth for GSK, pretending otherwise is an absolute lie and you know it. the fact that someone like bill (and doubtlessly many more) are running around on behalf of drug companies, making sure to get their advertising for something like this is a true statement to how well behaved the drug companies expect us consumers to be. the FDA is not to be trusted (phen-fen anyone?) and myalli will certainly be shown to be a scam in the future as well, more than likely resulting in huge lawsuits, and costing GSK a ton of money. (well, not really GSK, more like their stock holders, and insurance compaines, which will really just be passed on to all of us) people that want to lose weight, do some research online, and talk to friends and family, its not something that will bother them, and with enough research, you will find your own conclusions as to how to lose weight. 1-2 pounds a week is too damn slow for me, what i have been doing is this, slim-fast in the morning and noon, along with a full hydroxycut regiment. losing anywhere from 4-7 pounds a week, and im not hungry all the damn time (no fast food for dinner either)

also, i dont shit myself at work, or worry about anal leakage. pull your heads out of your oversized asses, use the net to do some research, and dont trust morons like bill here, you will sell his soul for a few dollars.
TruKuta, you sound like a fun person
written by Joe Smoe, July 27, 2007 04:49 PM
pull your heads out of your oversized asses, use the net to do some research


Umm, isn't anyone online reading about Alli doing exactly that? Maybe you should lay off the hydroxycut. It's making you bitchy.
There are better alternatives
written by IMS, September 21, 2007 12:20 PM
As someone who tried diet pills and used to go to the gym regularly, I empathize with others who are looking for ways to lose weight. Over the past few years I found better, more sustainable results by focusing on the way I eat. This is what works for me:

- Avoid processed foods and beverages.
- Minimize high-calorie beverages (sweetened drinks, beer, wine, etc) and have more water instead.
- Cut back on meat and dairy (
Better alternatives....
written by IMS, September 21, 2007 12:22 PM
Sorry, the post got cut off. This is what works for me:

- Avoid processed foods and beverages.
- Minimize high-calorie beverages (sweetened drinks, beer, wine, etc) and have more water instead.
- Cut back on meat and dairy (4oz total per day).
- Eat more fruits and vegetables.
- Avoid tough-to-digest food combinations: Try not to eat animal products (meat and dairy) with starch or grains in the same meal; Have fruit on an empty stomach and wait 30 minutes before eating other foods.

The guidelines for food combinations can get more complex, but the points listed above are a good place to start. Note that I am not a doctor or nutritionist, and I am not trying to sell you anything. It just seems like the average diet has the nutritional equivalent to eating flavored plastic and sawdust. There are better alternatives. And, by the way, high quality dark chocolate (70% cacao) is OK in moderate amounts.
The Lies Your Nutritionist Tells You...
written by Mikhail, February 24, 2008 01:35 AM
There is no magic pill. There is no magic formula. People are fat because our technology is fighting our evolution. Generations of humans dying from lack of food ensured that only those with genes that prompted them to overeat or overstore fat survived. Now that our technology makes it easy to get food, our bodies don't know how to cope. Our genes still scream at our brains to eat up in case of famine. Our bodies still store fat it doesn't need for the same reason.

Until someone finds out how to shut those parts of a human body down, we will continue, as a nation, to get fat and stay that way -- even if you decide to crap your pants for a couple years to lose the weight, it will come right back. Hell, even Oprah can't keep the weight off and that girl has enough money to hire an army of chefs and personal trainers to keep her thin. When are we going to learn that this just isn't about willpower or gimmicks!

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote

busy